Two Natural Deodorants, Two Different Approaches
Bend Soap Company offers two natural deodorants that are both aluminum-free and made with 100% natural ingredients, but they serve slightly different needs. The All Shield Natural Deodorant is a classic scent option that balances pH and fights odor without synthetic fragrances or parabens. The Vanilla Lavender Magnesium Deodorant uses magnesium hydroxide instead of baking soda, making it a gentler choice for those with sensitive skin. Here's how they compare so you can choose the right one for your routine.
What Each Formula Offers
- All Shield Natural Deodorant: This aluminum-free formula uses only 100% natural ingredients to help balance your pH, combat odor, and keep you feeling fresh all day, without harsh chemicals. All Shield is designed for users who want a reliable, classic deodorant that relies on natural pH balance rather than baking soda or aluminum.

All Shield Natural Deodorant - Vanilla Lavender Magnesium Deodorant (Baking Soda Free): Crafted with magnesium hydroxide to provide gentle, long-lasting odor protection without the irritation of baking soda or the pore-clogging effects of aluminum. The magnesium formula is specifically for people whose skin reacts to baking soda, offering a soothing alternative with coconut oil, shea butter, and chamomile.

Vanilla Lavender Magnesium Deodorant (Baking Soda Free)
Key Differences at a Glance
Both deodorants are natural, but the main difference is the active approach to odor control and skin sensitivity.
- Odor protection method: All Shield balances pH to combat odor; the Magnesium Deodorant uses magnesium hydroxide for gentle, long-lasting protection.
- Baking soda content: All Shield does not list baking soda as an ingredient but does not specifically advertise as baking soda free. The Magnesium Deodorant is explicitly baking soda free.
- Skin-soothing extras: The Magnesium Deodorant includes coconut oil, shea butter, and chamomile extract to soothe and moisturize. All Shield focuses on a clean, no-junk formula without those added butters.
- Scent: All Shield has a signature scent described as one of the most loved. Vanilla Lavender Magnesium Deodorant offers a calming vanilla and lavender fragrance.
- Price (catalog comparison price): All Shield: $7.35. Vanilla Lavender Magnesium Deodorant: $10.45.
Which One Should You Choose?
If you already love the All Shield scent and want a straightforward natural deodorant that balances pH without synthetic additives, the All Shield Natural Deodorant is a solid, affordable choice. It goes on smooth, absorbs moisture without stickiness, and leaves only freshness behind.
If you have sensitive skin that reacts to baking soda, or you prefer a deodorant with extra moisturizing ingredients like shea butter and chamomile, the Vanilla Lavender Magnesium Deodorant is the better pick. Its baking soda free formula is designed to be gentle while still providing effective odor protection.
Both are free from aluminum, parabens, synthetic fragrances, and GMOs. The choice comes down to your skin's tolerance and your scent preference.


